Editorial Policy

How these reviews are written and checked

The working standards behind every page on Film Notices: original sentences, labelled spoilers, and a clear line between what a film states and what a writer reads into it.

A page held flat with a steel ruler and pencil laid along its margin on a timber desk.

Original prose, checked before it is published

Film Notices is an independent editorial portal covering Reviews, Film History, Australian Cinema and Curated Lists. Every piece is written from scratch. Plot facts are researched, but the sentences are our own — no paraphrasing of working critics, and no lifting of summaries from databases, studio pages or streaming catalogues. Where a claim cannot be confirmed, it is left out rather than softened into something unfalsifiable.

Each published article carries a byline and a last-updated date, so a reader can see when a page last changed. House spelling follows Australian convention — favourite, colour, organise, recognised — and a style sheet of roughly 40 banned words and phrases is applied at the editing stage, covering clickbait verbs and tabloid phrasing. That sheet is not decoration: it is the stage where a sentence gets rewritten or cut.

Curated lists are editorial selections, not objective universal rankings, and each one opens with a standing line saying so. Film history explainers are written in plain language with a short timeline of dates attached, and Australian cinema pages pass a checklist that strips stereotype phrasing before publication.

Where fact ends and interpretation begins

Every article separates FACT from INTERPRETATION under two distinct headings, because a confirmed detail and a defensible reading carry different weight for a reader trying to understand a film.

Three edit stages before a page goes live

  1. 01

    Draft written from research

    In the draft stage, the writer assembles verified plot facts and credits first — title, year, country, runtime, director and cast — then writes the prose independently. Nothing is carried over from an existing review or summary, and quoted lines are kept short and attributed.

  2. 02

    Fact-check against two sources

    Film card fields — title, year, country, runtime, director and cast — and plot points are matched against at least two independent sources. A field that fails the check is left blank rather than filled with an approximation.

  3. 03

    Spoiler-leakage read

    A final pass exists for one purpose: catching twist material that has drifted into a headline, a card sentence, a meta description or the opening paragraphs above the SPOILER WARNING label.

  4. 04

    Publication with a date

    The piece goes live with a byline and a last-updated date, so a later change is visible to anyone who returns to the page.

  5. 05

    Corrections logged

    Reader tip-offs about errors are recorded with a reference number and answered with a note of what was changed. The corrections page sets out separate routes for factual corrections, copyright enquiries and content removal.

What a film page will never carry

The house rules that apply at the editing stage, applied the same way to every title.

The parameters the desk works to

The measurable settings behind the policy, so a reader knows what to expect from a page.

Film card fields
Title, year, country, runtime, director, cast
Unverified field
Left blank, never estimated
Plot confirmation
Two independent sources before publication
Spoiler labels in use
SPOILER-FREE and SPOILER WARNING, with expandable sections below the warning
Quote length
Short attributed lines only
Banned-phrase sheet
About 40 clickbait and tabloid terms, applied at edit
House spelling
Australian: favourite, colour, organise, recognised
Update line
Byline and last-updated date on every published piece
Corrections inbox
[email protected], logged with a reference number

Questions about how the standards are applied

Will a spoiler-free review ever mention a twist?

No. The SPOILER-FREE section stays above the warning, and full plot, major twists and ending explanations sit inside expandable sections further down. The same rule covers meta descriptions, search snippets and the one-sentence summary on a homepage card.

Why are there no star ratings anywhere?

Because a number flattens the argument. Assessment is written into the prose, where the reasoning can be seen and argued with, rather than compressed into a score that travels without context.

What happens when sources disagree about a plot point?

The point is either described in a way both sources support or left out. We do not resolve a disagreement by picking the more dramatic version, and we do not present a contested reading as settled fact.

Can I quote a Film Notices article?

Short quotations with attribution are fine. Reproducing a page in full, or republishing a substantial passage, needs a written request — copyright enquiries and content removal requests each have their own route on the corrections page.

How is creator intent handled?

It is stated only where a cited interview or commentary supports it. Without that evidence, an interpretation is labelled as interpretation instead of being attributed to the filmmakers.

What should I do if I spot an error?

Send the page address and the detail you believe is wrong to [email protected]. The tip-off is logged with a reference number, the page is checked against its sources, and you receive a note of the change made — or of the reason nothing changed.

Report a detail that does not hold up

Factual corrections, copyright enquiries and content removal requests each go through their own route. Write to [email protected] or call +61 404 475 346, and include the page address and the specific detail in question.

Contact the editors